Retail - Trading Down Phenomena has Outdoor Retailers Shopping Lower Price Points

Some outdoor specialty retailers are beginning to follow their customers down market. “I think people are scaling back on the number of $400 shells they are bringing in and buying more $100 shells,” said Dave Matz, president of Grassroots Outdoor Alliance. “There is a movement to bring in a lower price point.”

While fashion and luxury brands are much more vulnerable to the trend, average retail prices have declined in specialty outdoor channels thanks to a surge in sales of carry over product and a rise in sales of accessories, according to retail sales data for January released last week by Outdoor Industry Association (OIA) and Snowsports Industries America (SIA). SIA reported that while consumers snapped up accessories like hats, gloves, goggles, wax, parkas, fleece tops, sweaters and winter boots, they backed away from buying skis, boots, boards, and bindings.

In outdoor channels, the share of product sold in the fourth quarter that was priced under $25 grew to 17.5% in 2008 from 16.7% in 2007 and 16.0% in 2006, according to data compiled by Leisure Trends Group for the OIA Outdoor Topline Report. The share of product priced over $100, meanwhile, fell to 38.0% from 40.0% and 39.1% respectively. The trend became more pronounced in January, when sales of sub-$25 product grew to 22.7% of total outdoor sales from 18.7% in the same month a year earlier. Sales of $100-plus product fell to 33.0% of total sales from 38.0% a year earlier. The share of footwear sales priced under $25 nearly doubled to the 10% range.

While analysts warn against reading too much into January sales figures, consumer surveys are detecting the shift down market, particularly in apparel. In one survey published last month, 90.7% of Americans designated specialty shopping for apparel as expendable.

Even specialty retailers catering to a more affluent clientele are introducing lower price points. Their thinking is a shift in consumer buying habits toward value and will continue long after the recession ends. In Charlotte, NC, Jesse Brown’s Outdoors is bringing Columbia Sportswear apparel back into their shop for the first time in years. Owner Bill Bartee stopped buying Columbia years ago after deciding his future lay with brands not carried by big-box retailers. With consumer anxiety over the economy rising, Bartee will add product from Columbia’s PFG and Titanium lines to complement his assortment of Arc’teryx, Ex Officio, Patagonia, Mountain Hardwear and The North Face.

“We will still sell $500 Gore-Tex shells,” said Bartee, “But we will sell less of them. Columbia will bring a price-point to Jesse Brown’s that to a large extent is not available right now. We anticipate a backlash against luxury.”

Some retailers see the recession accelerating a long-term trend away from brand loyalty that was already being driven by the millennial generation (born 1978 - 2001). That generation is much less inclined to define themselves by conspicuous consumption of specific brands, said Ted Manning, VP of merchandising for Eastern Mountain Sports (EMS).

“The customer is coming back to the concept of minimalism and core functionality and not excess,” said Manning, “There will be less brand loyalty.”

Still, national brands will continue to play a major role at EMS, which continues to grow its own brand of apparel. “We have not headed into recession by throwing out national brands,” Manning said.

Below are examples of how retailers are adapting to consumers’ new frugality:

Loading up on basics and accessories that are priced below $25.

Shifting down within a brand. Rather than cut premium brands, buyers are bringing in more of their entry-level product. The good-better-best mix is shifting more toward better.

Bundling product on the equipment side to lower the cost of entry for your core sports. For instance, bundle a boat, PFD and paddle to show entry-level paddlers how inexpensively they can getting into paddle sports.

Bringing in new brands. Specialty retailers are giving more widely distributed value brands another look.

Expanding and/or promoting private label offerings.

Buying overstock and close-out deals. Many retailers who cut back their pre-season orders are aggressively buying overstock and closeouts to ensure a steady flow of deals.